The West Coast Regional Council has narrowly voted to keep its Local Government NZ (LGNZ) membership after hearing a "tsunami" of law change affecting councils will only intensify.
Chairman Allan Birchfield was not among those voting to retain LGNZ membership. Photo: LDR / Lois Williams
The council this week voted 4-3 to retain its membership after the national lobby group fronted councillors.
Chairman Allan Birchfield said he was voting "no" to put the group "on notice". Crs Peter Ewen and Brett Cummings also opposed.
Cr John Hill said LGNZ's advocacy role did not come across well.
"It's coming the opposite way: you are coming to local government advocating for central government," he said before voting in favour.
Crs Debra Magner and Stuart Challenger expressed similar views.
LGNZ president Stuart Crosby acknowledged the "dissatisfaction" about LGNZ's role in engaging with the government on the three waters issue.
However, its position on that had also been "grossly misrepresented," Crosby said.
"LGNZ took a position of trying to influence what we saw as a really bad model - and we still see it as a bad model.
"While we agree with a process and we agree with some principles, we do not and have not agreed with the model."
LGNZ had been pushing back at the government's reform model for nine months.
"We've been able quite successfully to date to change it and will continue through the bill process... we do have influence."
LGNZ has been able to get changes in the government's three waters plans, president Stuart Crosby says. Photo: RNZ/ Andrew McRae
However, he warned the council it needed to be represented given much deeper reform affecting local government was looming.
"The bigger game in town is the changes to the RMA [Resource Management Act]."
The combined district plan process imposed by the government on the West Coast's three territorial authorities was one such change now being signalled for the rest of the country.
"The one plan is, as I understand it, the direction of travel where the RMA changes are going," Crosby said.
Cr Laura Coll-McLaughlin Photo: LDR / Supplied
The regional council had been given the responsibility of drafting the combined plan, but it also came at cost to its ratepayers.
"You are leading in New Zealand in that space but you have to pay for that. We think we could have assisted in that process. At the end of the day, the power of one has an impact but the power of 77 [local] authorities has downright more in going to government."
Cr Laura Coll-McLaughlin acknowledged local government was about to go through "unprecedented change".
Cr Coll-McLaughlin said it was not a good idea for the regional council to "walk away" from LGNZ after noting the latter organisation's role in advocating for localism and placemaking in local government.
She noted that LGNZ was able to provide the council with a needed advocacy service at a time when local government was going through unprecedented change.
Powerless and constrained
Cr Hill said the council felt powerless and constrained in the face of law change as the government pushed through change in the current parliamentary term.
This made it very difficult for councils to adequately respond and consult as required, given they were now in the last quarter of the current three-year term.
"You mention...the power of 77, but what the ratepayers and the local councils are saying is that despite the power of 77, government is forging ahead. It's not just three waters. We have had a report today which lists the tsunami of new legislation and bills that central government are pushing for," Cr Hill said.
"It just doesn't fit the bill, if you pardon the pun...The timing is bad. They're forcing things through."
LGNZ chief executive Susan Freeman-Greene said the reality of the amount of law reform affecting local government was unrelenting with the government's absolute majority at present, while the "place making role" of councils was at risk through the Resource Management Act reform.
LGNZ had a role in this to ensure the "threads" of local community representation were included in reform.
"What we've got to make sure is that local voice is always front and centre."
Local Democracy Reporting is a public interest news service supported by RNZ, the News Publishers' Association and NZ On Air.
RELATED] https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/ldr/467045/councils-consider-ending-local-government-nz-membership