New Zealand / Business

Hundreds of jobs at risk under proposal to close Timaru meatworks

15:01 pm on 27 September 2024

Workers leave a surprise meeting where they were told they could lose their jobs. Photo: Tim Brown/RNZ

Alliance Group has announced a proposal to close its Smithfield meatworks in Timaru.

It told workers consultation would run until 11 October and a final decision was expected to be made by 18 October.

If the closure went ahead, Alliance said wherever possible it would offer workers the opportunity to apply for re-deployment at the company's other plants.

However it anticipated there would be a significant number of redundancies.

Photo: Alliance/supplied

The lamb processing season finished at the Smithfield plant on Wednesday. Venison processing was still running, but workers were told there were no shifts on Friday and to attend the meeting instead.

Alliance chief executive Willie Wiese said a decline in sheep processing numbers was behind the proposal.

"This proposal aims to align our operations with current livestock availability, ensuring we have the right scale and cost structure to meet future demands as a leading red meat processor.

"We simply cannot maintain excess processing capacity when livestock numbers don't support it. This proposal aims to align our operations with current livestock availability, ensuring we have the right scale and cost structure to meet future demands as a leading red meat processor.

"By optimising our capacity to match livestock flows, we can position ourselves for long-term success and reduce our cost base. We simply cannot maintain excess processing capacity when livestock numbers don't support it."

The 139-year-old Smithfield plant was the company's oldest site and required significant investment in repairs and maintenance to keep it operational. It was also facing encroachment from retail development.

"We know our people at Smithfield, their colleagues and the local community will be devastated by this proposal," Wiese said.

"Smithfield has a long and proud history, having been part of Alliance's network for more than 30 years. Our priority is to support affected employees during this immensely difficult period. We will also work closely with local authorities and support agencies and ensure the local community is informed, supported, and included in discussions."

'It's going to impact our family and the people around us' - Smithfield worker

One of the Alliance workers, Clint Agnew, started work at the plant 20 years ago and said staff were not given the chance to ask questions at Friday morning's meeting. Agnew was annoyed and upset about the proposal to close the meatworks.

"I'm feeling a bit torn up really, a bit emotional and yeah, a bit sad. Luckily I'm venison so I don't finish until December, but by then a lot of jobs will be taken because all the other fellas will go out and have found it."

Agnew said it was hard to find work in Timaru, but he would stay in the town.

Clint Agnew held back tears as he spoke about the colleagues he's had at 20 years at the plant. Photo: RNZ / Tim Brown

One woman, PJ, who works at Smithfield said after the meeting that everyone had been told they were losing their jobs, and Alliance was shutting the plant.

"It's a proposal but I can see it happening."

She said the news had come as a big blow and it was yet to fully sink in.

"This is a whole community, this is most of Timaru standing here so it's gonna hit real hard."

Wendy, left, and PJ after learning of Alliance Group's proposal to close the Timaru meat processing plant. Photo: RNZ / Tim Brown

Another Alliance employee said he was sad at the thought of losing his job at the Smithfield meatworks.

Samiuela Kolovatu, who is originally from Tonga, said the team at the meatworks were like family and the job had given him good skills and experience.

"It's a bit hard job, it's a good money job and now there are lots of families and friends who don't know what is going to happen in the long run."

He said the company had not given reasons for the closure but staff had been given a document and told to send the company any questions and feedback.

"For now it is not yet confirmed... but they said the proposal is to close the plant permanently and they told us they are going to look for opportunities for some of the workers at other plants but it is not guaranteed for everyone.

"It's going to impact our family and the people around us, there are so many people around here that are going to be looking for a job, it's hard... I don't know what is going to happen going forward."

He said if the plant did close he would stay in Timaru and try to find another job.

"It's really good money when we make it here, supports each other and family but for now, we just hold on."

Smithfield meat processing plant employee Samiuela Kolovatu. Photo: RNZ / Tim Brown

South Canterbury Chamber of Commerce chief executive Wendy Smith said it was a black Friday for Timaru.

"The immediate impact on those approximately 600 staff is absolutely terrible and our hearts go out to them.

"We will obviously ensure wherever we can that there are wraparound services for them, but this has a wider impact on all the service industries that support such a large business."

She said the meatworks was part of the region's agricultural, manufacturing and processing history and part of South Cantabrians DNA.

"It's been well publicised that the red meat industry has been through challenging times and that is a concern, we are hoping that there are some small green shoots starting to show ... but obviously there are some other issues we need to grapple with."

Smith said the chamber would be looking to see how it could support those affected and help to build up business again.

"The company themselves will obviously have a level of support and then it will be the Ministry of Social Development and the rest of our community to support them wherever we can."

Alliance workers after hearing about the proposed closure of their workplace. Photo: Tim Brown/RNZ

Surprise meeting called

On Thursday, the company announced a surprise meeting would be held at 11am on Friday. The company would not say in advance what it was about.

Alliance Group of Smithfield plant in South Canterbury. Photo: Alliance/supplied

Ahead of the meeting, Timaru Mayor Nigel Bowen said the plant employed more than 600 people at peak season, and workers were going into the meeting with a lot of questions.

"There's a lot of concern for those workers that are affected. There's been rumours for some time now around possible changes, potential closure, so I guess one thing that is positive is that affected parties will have that confirmed in one way or another."

Bowen said a closure would be significant for the region, given the large number of staff and supporting trades it would affect.

"We've been talking, certainly, with agencies, Chamber of Commerce, economic development, and certainly there'll be as much support as possible wrapped around anyone if there is any closure of sorts," he said.

Alliance reported a loss before tax of $97.9 million for the year ending September 2023. This loss was largely due to weakening global markets, changing land use that has resulted in lower livestock volumes, and inflationary pressures.