New Zealand ports are watching and waiting as one of their own tries to add a little grey to "black and white" legislation set up to preserve protected coastal areas.
The Supreme Court referred the case begun by Port Otago to the Court of Appeal earlier this year. Photo: LDR / Chloe Ranford
Port Otago is trying to push through a more flexible approach to signing off on port activities that could affect the environment, saying balance is better than a ban.
The Dunedin port - which fears it could close if changes are not made - has drafted in legal "heavy hitter" Marlborough District Council as backup, as the decision could have "serious ramifications" for the nation's ports.
It argues New Zealand's Coastal Policy Statement is being enforced "too rigidly", and wants consents for ports to be looked at on a case-by-case basis instead of falling under a blanket ban if they affect the environment.
Port Otago wants a more flexible approach to signing off on port activities that could affect the environment. Photo: Port Otago
The case is with the Court of Appeal after four years of legal talks. A court date has not yet been set.
Marlborough District Council advocacy and practice integration manager Barbara Mead said the case was not about dumping current legislation, but refining it.
"What if we need to put down a new guidance light buoy navigation system, and we wanted it put on seagrass, which was a protected piece of the environment?
"If there was no alternative location for the navigational system, then you'd have a direct conflict between the use of that port and our international obligation to provide a safe port against the avoidance policies."
The council's own port, Port Marlborough, would likely run into problems if rules were not made more flexible.
"At the moment we're skipping the whole analysing process. It's like going to the doctors and being given a bottle of pills, without having your blood pressure done."
Currently, a multimillion-dollar upgrade to Picton's ferry terminal - which Marlborough District Council and Port Marlborough were helping lead - was being fast-tracked to help with economic recovery following the lockdown.
Port Otago has ports at Port Chalmers and Dunedin.
Dispute over interpretation began in 2016
The dispute fired up in 2016 when the Otago Regional Council released its proposed regional policy statement.
The Environmental Defence Society said the statement failed to line up with avoidance policies and therefore would not protect the environment, which Port Otago disputed.
The Environment Court sided with Port Otago in 2018, saying the avoidance policies did not state ports had to avoid negatively affecting the environment in all cases.
The decision was appealed to the High Court on the grounds it was an "unlawful" breach of policies.
Port Otago and Marlborough's council opposed that appeal, but the High Court dismissed their argument that the Environment Court had "hit the nail on the head".
The pair tried taking their case to the Supreme Court, which said it was "one with real implications for the existing ports", but it was referred on to the Court of Appeal.
It would determine if the High Court was mistaken.
Mead said if the court found ports did not have to avoid negative environmental effects every time they developed, it would usurp a previous Supreme Court ruling that "avoid means avoid, there's no grey edge".
The ruling, made in 2014, centred on a request from New Zealand King Salmon to put down eight new fish farms in the Marlborough Sounds for 35 years.
The council was a "big player" in this case, she said.
The council managed the most coastline in New Zealand. It considered preserving the character of Marlborough's coastal environment's a matter of "national importance" under its environment plan.
Mead said the council saved time and money involving itself in the legal case now, rather than waiting for a final decision that it might not support and would have to challenge later.
Local Democracy Reporting is a public interest news service supported by RNZ, the News Publishers' Association and NZ on Air.