Tauranga and the Western Bay of Plenty have been directed to fluoridate their water supplies but one council has serious concerns about it.
Western Bay of Plenty Mayor Garry Webber had questions about funding the fluoridation. Photo: John Borren/Sun Media
Yesterday, director-general of health Dr Ashley Bloomfield announced 14 local authorities would be directed to add fluoride to some or all of their water supplies.
It is the first time this power has been used since the legislation was amended last year to ensure a "national approach" to fluoridating water.
This included Tauranga City Council and the Western Bay of Plenty District Council.
Dr Bloomfield instructed the city council to fluoridate all three of its water supplies and the district council must fluoridate two of its eight supplies.
The district council supplies were for Athenree and Wharawhara that covers Waihī Beach, Athenree, Tanners Point, Katikati and the reticulated rural area through to Morton Rd.
Western Bay of Plenty District Council had serious concerns with the directive.
Mayor Garry Webber said before council went any further there were several important questions that needed to be addressed.
"Yes, it's an instruction from the Ministry of Health but there needs to be clear direction on the funding of capital and ongoing operating costs," he said.
"We will be working hard to ensure there is no financial burden passed on to the community."
He also questioned why it was just two water supplies and the ongoing implications.
"Is this the beginning of fluoride being added to the entire district's water supply?"
The government offered a financial incentive by inviting council's to apply for a slice of the $11.3 million fund for capital projects associated with fluoridation.
Tauranga City Council chief executive Marty Grenfell said it was unclear what portion of the estimated $3.6m capital set up cost would be covered by the grant or how the expected operating costs of $175,000 a year would be funded.
Both Webber and Grenfell said the councils were obliged to follow the directive. Webber added if council did not comply it constituted an offence under the Health Act.
The water must be fluoridated at optimal levels, between 0.7 parts per million to 1 part per million. Tauranga city must comply by July 31 2024 and the Western Bay of Plenty by July 31 2025.
In 1992 Tauranga removed fluoride from its water supply after a referendum, where 51 per cent of people voted to stop adding it.
Bay of Plenty MP Todd Muller said the case for fluoridation was "pretty compelling" and he supported the two councils acting on the directive.
"I support council engagement with the government to ensure it's rolled out across our potable water infrastructure cost efficiently," said Muller.
New Zealand Dental Association Bay of Plenty spokesperson Rob Aitken said Dr Bloomfield needed to be congratulated for his direct stance on fluoridation.
"There's a huge need in New Zealand ... and something has to be done on a nationwide basis," said Aitken.
"Fluoridation is extremely beneficial to oral health. Is it the complete answer? No, of course not."
He said home care and twice daily brushing with a fluoride toothpaste were part of good oral health outcomes.
In his extensive career, including 12 years as the clinical director of community oral health at the Waikato District Health Board, Aitken has seen a decline in people's oral health.
"New Zealand's oral health status has decreased in the last 20 years. It's significant amongst our child and adolescent population."
He said a lot of it was dietary and due to sugary drinks, but fluoride still played an important role.
Aitken explained that fluoride makes teeth "less susceptible to acid attack" and the acid was caused by bacteria in the mouth turning sugar into acid.
"If you add fluoride to the drinking water or if you use fluorinated toothpaste, the enamel of your teeth is more resistant to acid attack and that's as simple as it is."
He estimated if fluoridation was rolled out nationwide then there would be a 20 to 40 per cent increase in people's oral health.
Aitken said he respected the opinions of those opposed to fluoridation but "science simply says that they're wrong".
"The overwhelming evidence is that water fluoridation at 0.7 parts per million is not injurious to general health."
Dr Bloomfield said fluoridation was proven to be a "safe, affordable and effective" method of preventing tooth decay.
"Community water fluoridation benefits everyone, but especially children, Māori, Pasifika and our most vulnerable," he said.
"Fluoridated water is safe for everyone to drink - including babies and the elderly - and fluoride exists naturally in air, soil, fresh water, sea water, plants and in food."
He pointed to the 2009 New Zealand oral health survey that showed that children and adolescents living in areas with fluoridated water have a 40 percent lower lifetime incidence of tooth decay than those living in areas without.
Dr Bloomfield said it was likely he would "actively consider" whether to issue further directions to fluoridate later this year.
Local Democracy Reporting is Public Interest Journalism funded through NZ On Air