New Zealand / Natural Disasters

Elderly couple trapped in storm repair limbo: 'I just can't live like this'

10:13 am on 27 March 2023

Rob and Mila Gaston's house was badly damaged after the Auckland Anniversary floods, and now they're dealing with leaks, mould and rat issues in their home. Photo: RNZ / Lucy Xia

An elderly West Auckland couple face many months of living in a storm-damaged house after the Anniversary Weekend flood wrecked walls and a tree punched a hole through the roof.

Rob Gaston, 76, and his wife Mila are still struggling to come to terms with the state of their Titirangi house on Wood Bay Road.

Rob Gaston is almost blind, and after weeks of staying with friends, the couple have returned to their yellow-stickered home because it is the only place he can navigate with his limited vision.

They also did not want to use up their insurance payout for accommodation assistance, hoping to save it for a rainy day.

A tree crashed through one of their second-floor bedrooms on the night of the storm, damaging windows, walls and parts of the roof - also killing both of the family's cats.

Mould is growing inside and the rats are moving in, but the couple said they have been told it may take until the end of the year before they get a cost estimate for repairs.

Two months after the storm, parts of a tree remains stuck through the window of a bedroom, and Gaston said Auckland Council won't let them remove the tree due to fears of destabilizing the slip bordering their house.

Rob Gaston has been left in limbo waiting for help with his home. Photo: RNZ / Lucy Xia

Gaston says an initial assessment was last month but they believe a cost assessment won't be done until November.

Consequently, the couple are reduced to living in one bedroom downstairs in the four-bedroom house, and continue to use the kitchen and bathroom upstairs - where the smell of mould lingers.

Gaston said even after they obtain the the cost assessment, it will may take until July next year before repairs can be completed given the shortage and high demand for contractors.

He said he is concerned about the winter months ahead.

"Can you imagine going through winter with it like this, and all the water getting into the spare bedroom all winter, and living with rats all winter?"

The tree has crashed into the Gastons' home. Photo: RNZ / Lucy Xia

Gaston said he is trying to negotiate with the council and their insurer, but may be forced to take matters into his own hands.

"I will find some way to get my excavator man in, and lift this tree out and I'll put a tarpaulin down here so I can keep the rain out of the house, because I have to do that.

"And keep the rats out of the house, and stop the mould growing on the ceiling, and stop the deterioration.

"I can't just live like this for that length of time and do nothing, it's ridiculous."

An EQC spokesperson said they have not been in direct contact with the Gastons, and that private insurers are managing all aspects of EQ cover claims on their behalf.

An IAG spokesperson said: "We are working through our claims as quickly as possible, prioritising customers who are unable to live in their homes. We are working alongside the relevant partners to do this".   

Auckland Council's manager of proactive compliance Adrian Wilson said Gaston has taken the appropriate steps by engaging with EQC to investigate the damage.

The council did not respond to questions relating to permission for Gaston to start removing the tree affecting his house.

Wilson said the council's Rapid Building Assessment Team will reach out to Gaston to review previous correspondence and scope of works in order to give them advice.

Listen to the report

  • Tens of thousands file claims over floods, slips
  • Flooding aftermath: Broken road, fumes, and fallen trees test tolerance levels in Titirangi
  • Slips, slides and no water - Titirangi suburb battered by storm fallout
  • Auckland floods: The Titirangi street teetering on the edge